Best Buy South: Setauket

The Best Buy originally located in (261 Pond Path) closed on October 19, 2025, and relocated to a new space in Stony Brook . The new store is approximately 2 miles away from the old site and now occupies the former Sports Authority location. New Store Location & Hours

You can drop off used batteries, light bulbs, and various electronics for recycling.

Staples, Michaels, Lowe's, Burlington, and Marshalls/HomeGoods. Entertainment: An AMC movie theater and Planet Fitness. best buy south setauket

Reviewers frequently highlight the knowledge and patience of staff members like "Nigel" and "Tom". However, some shoppers have noted long wait times for online order pickups during peak hours. Nearby Amenities

The store is typically most crowded on Saturday afternoons . For a quieter experience, try visiting on Sunday, Monday, or Wednesday mornings . The Best Buy originally located in (261 Pond

South Setauket Best Buy store relocates to Stony Brook - Newsday

The store is wheelchair accessible and provides free on-site parking. However, some shoppers have noted long wait times

The new location is part of a dense retail hub. It is adjacent to a shopping center featuring: